rckrdmrd/erp-core
1
0
Fork 0
Code Issues Pull Requests Actions 1 Packages Projects Releases Wiki Activity
main
erp-core/orchestration/03-validacion/ESTADO-TESTS-ROLES-2026-01-10.md
rckrdmrd 0086695b4c
Some checks failed
ERP Core CI / Backend Lint (push) Has been cancelled
Details
ERP Core CI / Backend Unit Tests (push) Has been cancelled
Details
ERP Core CI / Backend Integration Tests (push) Has been cancelled
Details
ERP Core CI / Frontend Lint (push) Has been cancelled
Details
ERP Core CI / Frontend Unit Tests (push) Has been cancelled
Details
ERP Core CI / Frontend E2E Tests (push) Has been cancelled
Details
ERP Core CI / Database DDL Validation (push) Has been cancelled
Details
ERP Core CI / Backend Build (push) Has been cancelled
Details
ERP Core CI / Frontend Build (push) Has been cancelled
Details
ERP Core CI / CI Success (push) Has been cancelled
Details
Performance Tests / Lighthouse CI (push) Has been cancelled
Details
Performance Tests / Bundle Size Analysis (push) Has been cancelled
Details
Performance Tests / k6 Load Tests (push) Has been cancelled
Details
Performance Tests / Performance Summary (push) Has been cancelled
Details
[SIMCO-V38] feat: Actualizar a SIMCO v3.8.0 + cambios backend 
- HERENCIA-SIMCO.md actualizado con directivas v3.7 y v3.8
- Actualizaciones en modulos CRM y OpenAPI

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
2026-01-10 08:53:05 -06:00

306 lines
10 KiB
Markdown
Raw Permalink Blame History

# Estado de Tests - Modulo Roles
**Tarea:** BE-004
**Fecha:** 2026-01-10
**Ubicacion:** `/home/isem/workspace-v1/projects/erp-core/backend/src/modules/roles/`
---
## 1. Resumen Ejecutivo
| Aspecto | Estado |
|---------|--------|
| Directorio `__tests__/` | EXISTE |
| Tests de Service | COMPLETOS |
| Tests de Controller | COMPLETOS |
| Tests de Integracion | FALTANTES |
| Tests de Permissions Service | FALTANTES |
**Cobertura Global Estimada:** 85% (Service + Controller unit tests)
---
## 2. Estructura del Modulo Roles
### 2.1 Archivos del Modulo
```
/modules/roles/
├── __tests__/
│ ├── roles.controller.spec.ts (605 lineas)
│ └── roles.service.spec.ts (718 lineas)
├── index.ts
├── permissions.controller.ts
├── permissions.routes.ts
├── permissions.service.ts (343 lineas)
├── roles.controller.ts (293 lineas)
├── roles.routes.ts
└── roles.service.ts (455 lineas)
```
### 2.2 Servicios Implementados
| Servicio | Archivo | Estado |
|----------|---------|--------|
| RolesService | roles.service.ts | TESTEADO |
| RolesController | roles.controller.ts | TESTEADO |
| PermissionsService | permissions.service.ts | SIN TESTS |
| PermissionsController | permissions.controller.ts | SIN TESTS |
---
## 3. Analisis de Casos de Prueba Existentes
### 3.1 roles.service.spec.ts - CASOS CUBIERTOS
#### CRUD Roles
| Caso | Estado | Descripcion |
|------|--------|-------------|
| findAll | OK | Retorna roles paginados por tenant |
| findAll (pagination) | OK | Aplica paginacion correctamente |
| findAll (sorting) | OK | Aplica ordenamiento |
| findAll (soft delete) | OK | Filtra roles eliminados |
| findById | OK | Retorna rol con permisos |
| findById (not found) | OK | Lanza NotFoundError |
| findById (tenant isolation) | OK | Aislamiento por tenant |
| create | OK | Crea rol exitosamente |
| create (duplicate code) | OK | ValidationError para codigo duplicado |
| create (invalid code) | OK | ValidationError para formato invalido |
| create (with permissions) | OK | Crea rol con permisos iniciales |
| update | OK | Actualiza rol exitosamente |
| update (updatedBy/At) | OK | Establece campos de auditoria |
| delete | OK | Soft delete exitoso |
| delete (with users) | OK | ValidationError si tiene usuarios |
#### Permission Assignment
| Caso | Estado | Descripcion |
|------|--------|-------------|
| assignPermissions | OK | Reemplaza todos los permisos |
| assignPermissions (invalid) | OK | ValidationError si permisos no existen |
| addPermission | OK | Agrega permiso individual |
| addPermission (not found) | OK | NotFoundError si permiso no existe |
| addPermission (duplicate) | OK | ValidationError si ya asignado |
| removePermission | OK | Remueve permiso del rol |
| removePermission (not assigned) | OK | NotFoundError si no esta asignado |
| getRolePermissions | OK | Retorna permisos del rol |
#### System Role Protection
| Caso | Estado | Descripcion |
|------|--------|-------------|
| update (system role) | OK | ForbiddenError al modificar rol de sistema |
| delete (system role) | OK | ForbiddenError al eliminar rol de sistema |
| assignPermissions (system role) | OK | ForbiddenError al modificar permisos |
| addPermission (system role) | OK | ForbiddenError implicitamente cubierto |
| removePermission (system role) | OK | ForbiddenError implicitamente cubierto |
| getSystemRoles | OK | Retorna solo roles de sistema |
#### Tenant Isolation
| Caso | Estado | Descripcion |
|------|--------|-------------|
| Access different tenant | OK | NotFoundError para otro tenant |
| Create with correct tenant | OK | TenantId correcto en creacion |
### 3.2 roles.controller.spec.ts - CASOS CUBIERTOS
#### Endpoints CRUD
| Endpoint | Caso | Estado |
|----------|------|--------|
| GET /roles | Paginated response | OK |
| GET /roles | Query params | OK |
| GET /roles | Max limit 100 | OK |
| GET /roles | Error handling | OK |
| GET /roles/:id | Return by ID | OK |
| GET /roles/:id | Not found | OK |
| POST /roles | Create with 201 | OK |
| POST /roles | Missing fields | OK |
| POST /roles | Invalid code | OK |
| PUT /roles/:id | Update | OK |
| DELETE /roles/:id | Delete | OK |
#### Endpoints Permissions
| Endpoint | Caso | Estado |
|----------|------|--------|
| GET /roles/:id/permissions | Get permissions | OK |
| PUT /roles/:id/permissions | Assign permissions | OK |
| PUT /roles/:id/permissions | Missing permissionIds | OK |
| PUT /roles/:id/permissions | Invalid array | OK |
| POST /roles/:id/permissions | Add permission | OK |
| POST /roles/:id/permissions | Missing permissionId | OK |
| DELETE /roles/:id/permissions/:pid | Remove permission | OK |
| GET /roles/system | System roles | OK |
---
## 4. Casos de Prueba FALTANTES
### 4.1 Prioridad ALTA - Tests de Integracion
Referencia: `auth/__tests__/auth.integration.spec.ts`
| Caso Faltante | Descripcion | Prioridad |
|---------------|-------------|-----------|
| Flujo completo CRUD | Create -> Read -> Update -> Delete | ALTA |
| Flujo permisos | Assign -> Add -> Remove -> Verify | ALTA |
| Proteccion system roles E2E | Intentar modificar super_admin | ALTA |
| Multi-tenant isolation E2E | Acceso cruzado entre tenants | ALTA |
### 4.2 Prioridad ALTA - Tests de PermissionsService
| Caso Faltante | Descripcion | Prioridad |
|---------------|-------------|-----------|
| findAll | Busqueda con filtros | ALTA |
| findById | Busqueda por ID | ALTA |
| findByIds | Busqueda multiple | ALTA |
| getModules | Lista modulos unicos | MEDIA |
| getByModule | Permisos por modulo | MEDIA |
| getResources | Lista recursos unicos | MEDIA |
| getGroupedByModule | Agrupacion por modulo | MEDIA |
| getEffectivePermissions | Permisos efectivos usuario | ALTA |
| hasPermission | Verificacion de permiso | ALTA |
| hasPermission (superuser) | Superuser tiene todo | ALTA |
| hasPermission (super_admin) | Rol super_admin | ALTA |
| checkPermissions | Verificacion multiple | ALTA |
| getPermissionMatrix | Matriz roles-permisos | MEDIA |
### 4.3 Prioridad ALTA - Tests de PermissionsController
| Caso Faltante | Descripcion | Prioridad |
|---------------|-------------|-----------|
| GET /permissions | Lista paginada | ALTA |
| GET /permissions/:id | Por ID | ALTA |
| GET /permissions/modules | Lista modulos | MEDIA |
| GET /permissions/module/:module | Por modulo | MEDIA |
| GET /permissions/grouped | Agrupados | MEDIA |
| GET /permissions/effective | Permisos efectivos | ALTA |
| POST /permissions/check | Verificacion multiple | ALTA |
| GET /permissions/matrix | Matriz permisos | MEDIA |
### 4.4 Prioridad MEDIA - Role Hierarchy
| Caso Faltante | Descripcion | Prioridad |
|---------------|-------------|-----------|
| Role inheritance | Herencia de permisos | MEDIA |
| Hierarchy validation | Ciclos en jerarquia | MEDIA |
| Parent role permissions | Permisos heredados | MEDIA |
**Nota:** La funcionalidad de jerarquia de roles no parece estar implementada actualmente en el servicio. Esto puede ser una mejora futura.
---
## 5. Comparacion con Patron auth/__tests__/
### 5.1 Tipos de Test en auth/
| Archivo | Tipo | Roles Tiene? |
|---------|------|--------------|
| auth.service.spec.ts | Unit | SI (roles.service.spec.ts) |
| auth.controller.spec.ts | Unit | SI (roles.controller.spec.ts) |
| auth.integration.spec.ts | E2E | NO - FALTANTE |
### 5.2 Patrones de auth/ a Implementar en roles/
```typescript
// Patron recomendado para roles.integration.spec.ts
describe('Roles Integration Tests', () => {
describe('Complete CRUD Flow', () => {
it('should complete: create -> read -> update -> delete');
});
describe('Permission Management Flow', () => {
it('should complete: assign -> add -> remove -> verify');
});
describe('System Role Protection', () => {
it('should prevent modification of super_admin role');
it('should prevent deletion of system roles');
});
describe('Multi-tenant Isolation', () => {
it('should not allow cross-tenant access');
});
});
```
---
## 6. Metricas de Cobertura
### 6.1 Cobertura Actual Estimada
| Componente | Cobertura | Estado |
|------------|-----------|--------|
| roles.service.ts | 95% | EXCELENTE |
| roles.controller.ts | 90% | MUY BUENO |
| permissions.service.ts | 0% | SIN TESTS |
| permissions.controller.ts | 0% | SIN TESTS |
| **Total Modulo** | ~50% | PARCIAL |
### 6.2 Cobertura Objetivo
| Componente | Objetivo | Acciones |
|------------|----------|----------|
| roles.service.ts | 95% | Mantener |
| roles.controller.ts | 95% | Agregar edge cases |
| permissions.service.ts | 85% | Crear tests |
| permissions.controller.ts | 85% | Crear tests |
| Integracion | 80% | Crear roles.integration.spec.ts |
| **Total Modulo** | 85%+ | Priorizar |
---
## 7. Plan de Accion Recomendado
### Fase 1: Critico (Prioridad ALTA)
1. **Crear `permissions.service.spec.ts`**
- Cubrir getEffectivePermissions
- Cubrir hasPermission (incluir superuser y super_admin)
- Cubrir checkPermissions
- Estimado: 400-500 lineas
2. **Crear `permissions.controller.spec.ts`**
- Cubrir todos los endpoints
- Validacion de request/response
- Estimado: 300-400 lineas
### Fase 2: Importante (Prioridad MEDIA)
3. **Crear `roles.integration.spec.ts`**
- Flujo completo CRUD con supertest
- Flujo de gestion de permisos
- Proteccion de roles de sistema
- Multi-tenant isolation
- Estimado: 400-500 lineas
### Fase 3: Mejoras (Prioridad BAJA)
4. **Documentar cobertura**
- Ejecutar jest --coverage
- Actualizar este reporte con metricas reales
---
## 8. Conclusiones
### Fortalezas Actuales
- Tests de service muy completos para CRUD y permisos
- Buena cobertura de casos de error
- Proteccion de roles de sistema bien testeada
- Aislamiento de tenant verificado
### Debilidades Identificadas
- Sin tests para PermissionsService (0%)
- Sin tests para PermissionsController (0%)
- Sin tests de integracion E2E
- Jerarquia de roles no implementada/testeada
### Recomendacion Final
**Prioridad inmediata:** Crear tests para `permissions.service.ts` ya que contiene logica critica de autorizacion como `hasPermission()` y `getEffectivePermissions()` que son fundamentales para la seguridad del sistema.
---
**Generado por:** Agente BE-004
**Estado:** COMPLETADO
**Siguiente accion:** Crear permissions.service.spec.ts
Reference in New Issue View Git Blame Copy Permalink