rckrdmrd/trading-platform
1
0
Fork 0
Code Issues Pull Requests Actions Packages Projects Releases Wiki Activity
8f0235c096
trading-platform/docs/_archive/REPORTE-TRAZABILIDAD-DDL.md
Adrian Flores Cortes 8f0235c096 [TASK-2026-02-06-ANALISIS-INTEGRAL-DOCUMENTACION] docs: Complete 6-phase documentation analysis 
- FASE-0: Diagnostic audit of 500+ files, 33 findings cataloged (7P0/8P1/12P2/6P3)
- FASE-1: Resolved 7 P0 critical conflicts (ports, paths, dedup OQI-010/ADR-002, orphan schemas)
- FASE-2: Resolved 8 P1 issues (traces, README/CLAUDE.md, DEPENDENCY-GRAPH v2.0, DDL drift, stack versions, DoR/DoD)
- FASE-3: Resolved 12 P2 issues (archived tasks indexed, RNFs created, OQI-010 US/RF/ET, AGENTS v2.0)
- FASE-4: Purged 3 obsolete docs to _archive/, fixed MODELO-NEGOCIO.md broken ref
- FASE-5: Cross-layer validation (DDL→OQI 66%, OQI→BE 72%, BE→FE 78%, Inventories 95%)
- FASE-6: INFORME-FINAL, SA-INDEX (18 subagents), METADATA COMPLETED

27/33 findings resolved (82%), 6 P3 deferred to backlog.
18 new files created, 40+ modified, 4 archived.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.6 <noreply@anthropic.com>
2026-02-06 10:57:03 -06:00

412 lines
14 KiB
Markdown
Raw Blame History

---
id: "REPORTE-TRAZABILIDAD-DDL"
title: "Documentacion vs DDL"
type: "Documentation"
project: "trading-platform"
version: "1.0.0"
updated_date: "2026-01-04"
---
# REPORTE DE TRAZABILIDAD: Documentacion vs DDL
**Fecha:** 2025-12-06
**Ejecutado por:** Requirements-Analyst Agent
**Version:** 1.1.0 (Actualizado con correcciones)
**Ultima actualizacion:** 2025-12-06
---
## RESUMEN EJECUTIVO
Se realizo un analisis exhaustivo comparando la documentacion de requisitos (8 epicas) contra los DDL implementados (8 schemas, 63 tablas).
### Metricas Globales
| Metrica | Valor | Estado |
|---------|-------|--------|
| Schemas analizados | 8 | - |
| Tablas implementadas | 67 | - |
| Tablas documentadas | ~55 | - |
| Cobertura promedio | 95% | ALINEADO |
| Decisiones arquitectonicas | 7/7 | 100% |
| Gaps criticos | 0 | RESUELTO |
| Gaps menores | 0 | RESUELTO |
| Extras positivos | 15 | OK |
### Estado por Epica
| Epica | Schema | Cobertura | Estado |
|-------|--------|-----------|--------|
| OQI-001 Auth | auth | 100% | ALINEADO |
| OQI-002 Education | education | 95% | ALINEADO |
| OQI-003 Trading | trading | 95% | ALINEADO |
| OQI-004 Investment | investment | 100% | ALINEADO |
| OQI-005 Payments | financial | 95% | ALINEADO |
| OQI-006 ML Signals | ml | N/A | SOBRE-IMPLEMENTADO |
| OQI-007 LLM Agent | llm | 100% | ALINEADO |
| - | audit | N/A | EXTRA |
---
## VERIFICACION DE DECISIONES ARQUITECTONICAS
| ID | Decision | Estado | Verificacion |
|----|----------|--------|--------------|
| DEC-001 | USD como moneda principal | CUMPLIDO | currency_exchange_rates implementado |
| DEC-002 | Delimitacion PAMM vs Portfolio | CUMPLIDO | investment solo para PAMM |
| DEC-003 | auth.users (no public.users) | CUMPLIDO | Todas las FKs usan auth.users |
| DEC-004 | pgvector para embeddings | CUMPLIDO | llm.embeddings con vector(1536) |
| DEC-005 | Distribucion PAMM mensual | CUMPLIDO | distribution_frequency enum |
| DEC-006 | trading.signals como interfaz ML | CUMPLIDO | Interfaz desacoplada |
| DEC-007 | TIMESTAMPTZ everywhere | CUMPLIDO | Verificado en todos los DDL |
---
## ANALISIS POR SCHEMA
### 1. AUTH (OQI-001) - 85% COBERTURA
**Tablas: 10**
| Tabla | Doc | DDL | Estado |
|-------|-----|-----|--------|
| users | SI | SI | ALINEADO (85%) |
| user_profiles | SI | SI | ALINEADO |
| oauth_accounts | SI | SI | ALINEADO |
| sessions | SI | SI | PARCIAL (estructura diferente) |
| email_verifications | SI | SI | ALINEADO |
| phone_verifications | SI | SI | PARCIAL (falta channel enum) |
| password_reset_tokens | SI | SI | ALINEADO |
| auth_logs | SI | SI | MEJORADO (particionado) |
| login_attempts | NO | SI | EXTRA (positivo) |
| rate_limiting_config | NO | SI | EXTRA (positivo) |
**Gaps Criticos:**
1. ENUM `phone_channel_enum` (sms, whatsapp) - Faltante
2. Campo `backup_codes` en users - Faltante
3. Valor 'twitter' en oauth_provider - Faltante
**Extras Positivos:**
- login_attempts (seguridad)
- rate_limiting_config (configuracion dinamica)
- Particionamiento en auth_logs
---
### 2. EDUCATION (OQI-002) - 95% COBERTURA
**Tablas: 14**
| Tabla | Doc | DDL | Estado |
|-------|-----|-----|--------|
| categories | SI | SI | ALINEADO |
| courses | SI | SI | ALINEADO |
| modules | SI | SI | ALINEADO |
| lessons | SI | SI | ALINEADO |
| enrollments | SI | SI | ALINEADO |
| progress | SI | SI | ALINEADO |
| quizzes | SI | SI | ALINEADO |
| quiz_questions | SI | SI | ALINEADO |
| quiz_attempts | SI | SI | ALINEADO |
| certificates | SI | SI | ALINEADO |
| user_achievements | SI | SI | ALINEADO |
| user_gamification_profile | NO | SI | EXTRA (necesario) |
| user_activity_log | NO | SI | EXTRA (necesario) |
| course_reviews | NO | SI | EXTRA (necesario) |
**Gaps Menores:**
- Verificar ENUMs en 00-enums.sql
- Verificar triggers/funciones
**Extras Positivos:**
- 3 tablas adicionales que implementan funcionalidad documentada en RFs
---
### 3. TRADING (OQI-003) - 60% COBERTURA
**Tablas: 9**
| Tabla | Doc | DDL | Estado |
|-------|-----|-----|--------|
| watchlists | SI | SI | ALINEADO (falta color) |
| watchlist_items | SI (watchlist_symbols) | SI | PARCIAL (normalizado) |
| orders | SI (paper_orders) | SI | DIVERGENTE (generico) |
| positions | SI (paper_positions) | SI | DIVERGENTE (con bot_id) |
| trades | SI (paper_trades) | SI | PARCIAL |
| paper_balances | SI | NO | FALTANTE CRITICO |
| symbols | NO | SI | EXTRA (necesario) |
| bots | NO | SI | EXTRA (fuera de alcance?) |
| signals | NO | SI | EXTRA (DEC-006) |
| trading_metrics | NO | SI | EXTRA |
**Gaps Criticos:**
1. Tabla `paper_balances` - BLOQUEA RF-TRD-004
2. Funcion `initialize_paper_balance()` - FALTANTE
3. Trigger `create_default_watchlist()` - FALTANTE
4. ENUM `position_side_enum` (long/short) - FALTANTE
5. Campos `current_quantity`, `average_entry_price` - FALTANTES
**Divergencia Conceptual:**
- Doc: Paper trading manual
- DDL: Trading automatizado con bots
---
### 4. INVESTMENT (OQI-004) - 60% COBERTURA
**Tablas: 5**
| Tabla | Doc | DDL | Estado |
|-------|-----|-----|--------|
| products | SI | SI | ALINEADO |
| accounts | SI | SI | ALINEADO |
| transactions | SI | SI | ALINEADO |
| distributions | SI | SI | ALINEADO |
| withdrawal_requests | SI | NO | FALTANTE |
| daily_performance | SI | NO | FALTANTE |
| risk_questionnaire | NO | SI | EXTRA (DEC-002) |
**Gaps:**
1. Tabla `withdrawal_requests` - Importante
2. Tabla `daily_performance` - Importante
---
### 5. FINANCIAL (OQI-005) - 55% COBERTURA
**Tablas: 8**
| Tabla | Doc | DDL | Estado |
|-------|-----|-----|--------|
| wallets | NO | SI | EXTRA (unificacion critica) |
| wallet_transactions | SI | SI | MEJORADO |
| subscriptions | SI | SI | ALINEADO |
| payments | SI | SI | PARCIAL |
| invoices | SI | SI | ALINEADO |
| customers | SI | NO | FALTANTE |
| payment_methods | SI | NO | FALTANTE |
| refunds | SI | NO | FALTANTE (workaround existe) |
| wallet_audit_log | NO | SI | EXTRA |
| currency_exchange_rates | NO | SI | EXTRA (DEC-001) |
| wallet_limits | NO | SI | EXTRA |
**Gaps:**
1. Tabla `customers` - Importante para Stripe
2. Tabla `payment_methods` - Medio
3. Tabla `refunds` - Bajo (workaround)
---
### 6. ML (OQI-006) - SOBRE-IMPLEMENTADO
**Tablas: 5**
| Tabla | Doc | DDL | Estado |
|-------|-----|-----|--------|
| models | NO | SI | EXTRA |
| model_versions | NO | SI | EXTRA |
| predictions | NO | SI | EXTRA |
| prediction_outcomes | NO | SI | EXTRA |
| feature_store | NO | SI | EXTRA |
**Nota:** La documentacion OQI-006 no especifica tablas de BD. DDL implementa sistema completo de ML operations.
---
### 7. LLM (OQI-007) - 100% COBERTURA
**Tablas: 5**
| Tabla | Doc | DDL | Estado |
|-------|-----|-----|--------|
| conversations | SI | SI | ALINEADO |
| messages | SI | SI | ALINEADO |
| user_preferences | SI | SI | ALINEADO |
| user_memory | SI | SI | ALINEADO |
| embeddings | SI | SI | ALINEADO (DEC-004) |
---
### 8. AUDIT - EXTRA COMPLETO
**Tablas: 7**
| Tabla | Proposito |
|-------|-----------|
| audit_logs | Log general |
| security_events | Eventos de seguridad |
| system_events | Eventos del sistema |
| trading_audit | Auditoria de trading |
| api_request_logs | Logs de API |
| data_access_logs | Acceso a datos (GDPR) |
| compliance_logs | Cumplimiento regulatorio |
**Nota:** Schema completo no documentado en epicas pero necesario para compliance.
---
## GAPS CORREGIDOS (2025-12-06)
### Prioridad P0 (Bloquean MVP) - TODOS RESUELTOS
| ID | Schema | Gap | Estado | Archivo |
|----|--------|-----|--------|---------|
| GAP-001 | trading | Tabla `paper_balances` | RESUELTO | tables/10-paper_balances.sql |
| GAP-002 | trading | Funcion `initialize_paper_balance()` | RESUELTO | functions/03-initialize_paper_balance.sql |
| GAP-003 | trading | Trigger `create_default_watchlist()` | RESUELTO | functions/04-create_default_watchlist.sql |
| GAP-004 | financial | Tabla `customers` | RESUELTO | tables/09-customers.sql |
### Prioridad P1 (Importantes) - TODOS RESUELTOS
| ID | Schema | Gap | Estado | Archivo |
|----|--------|-----|--------|---------|
| GAP-005 | auth | ENUM `phone_channel` | RESUELTO | 01-enums.sql |
| GAP-006 | auth | Campo `backup_codes` | RESUELTO | tables/01-users.sql |
| GAP-007 | investment | Tabla `withdrawal_requests` | RESUELTO | tables/06-withdrawal_requests.sql |
| GAP-008 | investment | Tabla `daily_performance` | RESUELTO | tables/07-daily_performance.sql |
### Prioridad P2 (Medios) - TODOS RESUELTOS
| ID | Schema | Gap | Estado | Archivo |
|----|--------|-----|--------|---------|
| GAP-009 | trading | ENUM `position_side_enum` | N/A | Usa order_side existente |
| GAP-010 | trading | Campos posiciones parciales | RESUELTO | tables/06-positions.sql |
| GAP-011 | financial | Tabla `payment_methods` | RESUELTO | tables/10-payment_methods.sql |
| GAP-012 | auth | 'twitter' en oauth_provider | RESUELTO | 01-enums.sql |
---
## EXTRAS POSITIVOS (NO DOCUMENTADOS)
### Tablas Adicionales Necesarias
| Schema | Tabla | Justificacion |
|--------|-------|---------------|
| auth | login_attempts | Seguridad |
| auth | rate_limiting_config | Configuracion |
| education | user_gamification_profile | RF-EDU-006 |
| education | user_activity_log | RF-EDU-003 |
| education | course_reviews | Reviews mencionadas |
| trading | symbols | Normalizacion |
| trading | signals | DEC-006 |
| investment | risk_questionnaire | DEC-002 |
| financial | wallets | Unificacion |
| financial | currency_exchange_rates | DEC-001 |
| financial | wallet_limits | Compliance |
| financial | wallet_audit_log | Auditoria |
| ml | (5 tablas) | MLOps completo |
| audit | (7 tablas) | Compliance |
---
## RECOMENDACIONES
### Acciones Inmediatas (Sprint Actual)
1. **Crear `trading.paper_balances`** - 4h
2. **Crear funciones/triggers de trading** - 6h
3. **Agregar ENUM `phone_channel_enum`** - 1h
4. **Agregar `backup_codes` a users** - 1h
5. **Agregar 'twitter' a oauth_provider** - 0.5h
**Total: ~12.5 horas**
### Acciones de Corto Plazo
6. **Crear `financial.customers`** - 4h
7. **Crear `investment.withdrawal_requests`** - 4h
8. **Crear `investment.daily_performance`** - 3h
9. **Actualizar documentacion ET-*-database.md** - 8h
**Total: ~19 horas**
### Acciones de Documentacion
10. **Crear ET-ML-006-database.md** para schema ml
11. **Crear ET-LLM-007-database.md** para schema llm
12. **Actualizar ET-TRD-003** con estado real
13. **Documentar schema audit**
---
## MATRIZ DE TRAZABILIDAD
### Requerimientos Funcionales vs Tablas DDL
| RF | Tablas Requeridas | Tablas Implementadas | Cobertura |
|----|-------------------|---------------------|-----------|
| RF-AUTH-001 OAuth | oauth_accounts | oauth_accounts | 95% |
| RF-AUTH-002 Email/Pass | users, email_verif | users, email_verif | 100% |
| RF-AUTH-003 Phone | phone_verif | phone_verif | 90% |
| RF-AUTH-004 2FA | users (backup_codes) | users | 80% |
| RF-AUTH-005 Sessions | sessions | sessions | 75% |
| RF-EDU-001 Catalogo | categories, courses | categories, courses | 100% |
| RF-EDU-002 Lecciones | modules, lessons | modules, lessons | 100% |
| RF-EDU-003 Progreso | enrollments, progress | enrollments, progress | 100% |
| RF-EDU-004 Quizzes | quizzes, quiz_* | quizzes, quiz_* | 100% |
| RF-EDU-005 Certificados | certificates | certificates | 100% |
| RF-EDU-006 Gamificacion | user_achievements | user_achievements + | 100% |
| RF-TRD-003 Watchlists | watchlists | watchlists | 95% |
| RF-TRD-004 Paper Trading | paper_balances, orders | orders | 40% |
| RF-TRD-005 Ordenes | orders | orders | 80% |
| RF-TRD-006 Posiciones | positions | positions | 60% |
| RF-INV-001 PAMM | products, accounts | products, accounts | 100% |
| RF-INV-002 Distribuciones | distributions | distributions | 100% |
| RF-PAY-001 Suscripciones | subscriptions | subscriptions | 100% |
| RF-PAY-002 Pagos | payments | payments | 90% |
| RF-ML-001 Predicciones | - | ml.predictions | 100%+ |
| RF-LLM-001 Chat | conversations, messages | conversations, messages | 100% |
---
## CONCLUSIONES
### Estado General: ALINEADO (95%)
**Fortalezas:**
1. 7/7 decisiones arquitectonicas implementadas correctamente
2. Todos los schemas principales alineados con documentacion
3. Extras positivos mejoran la arquitectura
4. Unificacion de wallets exitosa
5. Interfaz ML (signals) bien implementada
6. Todos los gaps P0, P1 y P2 resueltos
**Debilidades Restantes:**
1. Documentacion desactualizada en algunos modulos (ET-*.md)
2. Faltan especificaciones de BD formales para ML y LLM
### Proximos Pasos Sugeridos
1. **Documentacion:** Actualizar ET-*-database.md para reflejar DDL actual
2. **Validacion:** Ejecutar DDL en entorno de pruebas para verificar integridad
3. **Backlog:** Crear ET-ML-006-database.md y ET-LLM-007-database.md
---
## HISTORIAL DE CORRECCIONES
### 2025-12-06 - Version 1.1.0
**Archivos Creados:**
- `trading/tables/10-paper_balances.sql` - Balance virtual para paper trading
- `trading/functions/03-initialize_paper_balance.sql` - Funciones de gestion de balance
- `trading/functions/04-create_default_watchlist.sql` - Trigger para nuevos usuarios
- `financial/tables/09-customers.sql` - Integracion Stripe customers
- `financial/tables/10-payment_methods.sql` - Metodos de pago guardados
- `investment/tables/06-withdrawal_requests.sql` - Solicitudes de retiro PAMM
- `investment/tables/07-daily_performance.sql` - Snapshots diarios + vista mensual
**Archivos Modificados:**
- `auth/01-enums.sql` - Agregado phone_channel enum, twitter a oauth_provider
- `auth/tables/01-users.sql` - Agregado campo backup_codes
- `auth/tables/06-phone_verifications.sql` - Agregado campo channel
- `trading/tables/06-positions.sql` - Agregados current_quantity, average_entry_price
**Total:** 7 tablas nuevas, 4 archivos modificados, 12 gaps resueltos
---
*Reporte generado automaticamente*
*Trading Platform*
Reference in New Issue View Git Blame Copy Permalink